Ready for wedding caterer red flags?
As a little disclaimer, I want to give a shout out to the many, many, many legit wedding caterers out there. You all work super hard. The food you create, the setup, and the serving of hungry people is not an easy task to coordinate and make happen. I see you. We all see you. Thank you for your service.
Now, onto the not-so-great wedding caterers. The ones with red flags.
And just so we’re all on the same page, red flags refer to warning signs. The things that come up while you’re getting to know someone that just don’t seem right. The types of things that you look back on later, when you find out someone wasn’t legit, and think, “I should have seen this coming”. Those are what I mean by red flags.
11 Wedding Caterer Red Flags You Need To Know
This post is going to go into eleven wedding caterer red flags. Warning signs that you should not be working with this particular business or person. In some cases, knowing wedding caterer red flags will prevent you from signing a contract. In other cases, you may need to figure out creative ways to get out of an arrangement or leave a deposit behind. The key here is to make sure non-legit wedding caterers (who may be scamming), do not ruin your wedding. A little nimbleness now can save stress later on.
Let’s get into it!
1. THE CATERER HAS TERRIBLE REVIEWS
One major wedding caterer red flag is terrible reviews.
I’m talking about reviews you can read online, that is.
Yelp. Wedding Wire. Google. They are filled with reviews. The reviews are free to read, all you need to do is take the time to do so. And, yes, some bad reviews can be expected for just about any business. You do need to take them with a grain of salt. However, if you see review after review that indicates the caterer isn’t reliable, is disorganized, doesn’t stick to their contract, or is just plain bad, don’t go with them. And, if you have already left a deposit, see if you can change course before it’s too late.
2. THE WEDDING CATERER DOESN’T RESPOND TO YOU
Unresponsiveness is a big red flag.
This can be at any point in the process. When you’re first looking for information on the wedding caterer’s availability. Or, when you’ve met them, signed a contract, and have some questions. Obviously, non-responsiveness is a red flag as you get close to your wedding date.
The worry here is of course, that your caterer will ghost your wedding. So, try to get a hold of the caterer in a few different ways. Call them. Email them. Send them a DM. Go by their shop, if you have to. Everyone gets busy, it happens. If you really, really, can’t reach them, move on or find a new path for your own peace of mind, no matter where you are in your wedding planning schedule. There’s always another option.
3. THE WEDDING CATERER WON’T LET YOU DO A TASTING
We all know what a tasting is, right?
If not, a tasting is when you get to taste the food that will be served before your wedding. The tasting may be a preview, or it may be a sampler so you can decide what you like. Not every tasting is private. Some are big events, depending on the caterer. Others may cost money and not be included with the cost of catering.
The key here is that you get to have a tasting before your wedding, somehow, someway. It’s a major wedding caterer red flag if they don’t allow it.
4. THE CATERER IS NEW TO WEDDINGS, OR CATERING IN GENERAL
Okay, okay. We all start somewhere.
Here’s my stance on wedding caterers who are just starting out. Some are going to be amazing. Others will be very, very green. If I’m about to hire a caterer who is new to weddings, I’d want them to be experienced with large events. Corporate parties, for example. Large birthday parties. Something with a crowd. If they don’t at least have that, I don’t really want them to test out their abilities on my wedding, ya know what I mean?
5. THE WEDDING CATERER WON’T LET YOU CUSTOMIZE THE FOOD, LIKE AT ALL
Major wedding caterer red flags if they won’t let you customize the food you’re about to pay for.
Some boundaries are okay, of course. However, caterers should be used to requests by now. Dietary restrictions, allergies, and just plain preference come into play here. In some cases, refusing to customize can mean major health risks for your or your guests. And, if you’re going to pay someone a bunch of money for a product, you should really want that product.
If your caterer won’t budget on their ingredients, it’s a sign that they are inflexible or unimaginative. At the very least, they aren’t about customer service. Move on.
6. THE WEDDING CATERER’S CONTRACT INCLUDES UNEXPECTED OR INCONSISTENT LANGUAGE
Most people aren’t used to reading contracts in general, let alone wedding contracts. Because of this, it can be hard to tell if something is common in a contract, or out of the ordinary.
Here’s what I suggest. Always read your contracts. When in doubt about certain language, ask your wedding planner, day of coordinator, Google, or a social media group what they think. Some things are standard, and others are quite strange.
If you find some language in a contract, especially if it contradicts what a caterer said to you in person, feel free to ask them about it. It’s a red flag if they get defensive, or seem confused, or brush off your question. If the language is clearly not okay, even if it’s standard, that is also a red flag that you may not want to work with this business.
7. THE WEDDING CATERER’S LOCATION SEEMS UNSANITARY
When it comes to food, we don’t want to mess around.
Even legit businesses with great reviews can have unsanitary conditions. And, look, dirt happens. Some missed wipes here and there are probably okay. However, if you go to a caterer’s location and see clear health violations, you may want to reconsider working with them. Look for things like bugs, rodents, droppings, cold items that get left out, bad smells, food cooking in dirty dishes, that sort of thing. Follow your gut on this one. You don’t want your guests being exposed to bacteria that can get them sick.
8. THE CATERER GIVES OFF UNORGANIZED VIBES
I don’t know about you, but disorganization drives me crazy.
Big wedding caterer red flags if they seem disorganized. Huge. I mean, best case scenario is that they forget to track your catering preferences. Worst case scenario is that they forget to show up to your wedding. The risk is just so high.
The warning signs for this red flag is that you have to remind the caterer multiple times what you’re ordering, or they confirm your requests or details with you and they are incorrect. You may also hear them actually tell you that they have trouble keeping track of things, or that they are disorganized.
And look, you don’t need to fire a caterer just for being disorganized. But you do need to micro manage them. Which may be enough for you to walk away.
9. THE CATERING STAFF SEEMS RUDE
Who wants to give money to someone who is rude? Not me!
Catering staff need to have some sort of presence around clients, even if they aren’t people-people. This means that they respond to questions. Requests. Seem polite on the phone. Give clients their attention when you are right in front of their face.
If you find that a caterer, or their staff, is rude to you, imagine how they may treat your wedding guests (the people who aren’t paying them). In this scenario, don’t be afraid to speak up. Let management know what you are seeing and see if the situation can be remedied. If not, reconsider your options, even if the food is amazing.
10. THE WEDDING CATERER HAS NO SOCIAL MEDIA, OR AN OUTDATED WEBSITE
If a potential, or confirmed, wedding caterer has no social media, or an outdated website, it’s a huge red flag.
Yes, I know, we all get busy. Chances are they may have created a website a long time ago and it’s just not maintained. It happens. But social media? It really doesn’t take much effort to create a page and throw some pics on it once in a while.
Here’s the thing. A lack of presence online can indicate that things have gone downhill for a previously organized caterer. It can also indicate a scam. If you find that this is the case for a caterer, and it’s paired with other red flags, it’s time to do some more investigation.
11. YOU DON’T LIKE THE FOOD THAT YOU’RE TASTING
Last one!
This isn’t one of the call-the-better-business-bureau kind of wedding caterer red flags, but it’s still worth noting.
If you hire a caterer, and go to do the tasting, and don’t like the food, you may have an issue. Maybe it’s you. However, if the people you bring to the tasting with you agree that the food isn’t great, you may be wasting your time with this caterer. Food is important at weddings, to just about everyone. It’s pointless to pay for food no one wants to eat.
In this instance, you may want to see if the caterer will take some feedback and modify their recipes, or you may want to cut your loses and find someone else.
THOUGHTS ON WEDDING CATERER RED FLAGS
Friends, there are tons and tons of amazing caterers out there who are legit, delicious, and wonderful to work with. There’s no reason you need to waste time or effort with those who present wedding caterer red flags. Yes, in some instances, you may lose a deposit if you walk away. It may be worth it to reduce stress. Wedding food is important and you don’t want to mess with a caterer who isn’t up to par. Happy wedding planning!
More On Wedding Catering From Hummingbird Wedding Advice
How To Save Money On Wedding Catering
The Basics of Wedding Catering (And What To Watch Out For)
21 Easy Finger Foods For Your Wedding Cocktail Hour
Did you find this post helpful, inspiring? PIN it to your Wedding Food Board on Pinterest!







Leave a Reply